Showing posts with label pop. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pop. Show all posts

29 May 2016

Cat Stevens—Numbers

Cat StevensNumbers (1975)
Numbers—Cat Stevens had a run of albums from 1970–1977 that resulted in four Platinum records (two 3x Platinum) and another four Gold. Calling him a hit-maker is an understatement—he had a string of eleven U.S. Top 40 hits during that same period that are still ingrained in public consciousness, mainly thanks to muzak. Every LP he put out in the wake of Tea for the Tillerman 1970) and Teaser and the Firecat (1971) had at least one notable hit that kept it from obscurity; it could be said that Stevens' business model was top-notch, if it's examined coldly. However, Stevens was more sensitive than that; he seemed to believe in his ideals, at least to some extent, and he was artful. Following Buddha and the Chocolate Box (1974), he tried something completely different.
Numbers
A Pythagorean Theory Tale

Further away from our Earth than it is possible to imagine, there was a galaxy. And almost in the center of the galaxy was a little planet called Polygor.
Polygor existed to give numbers to the universe. Number 1, number 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8 and 9. Each day millions and billions and zillions of numbers were distributed to every world that needed them [...]
Numbers is Cat Stevens/Yusuf Islam's only clear concept album, and while it seems arcane, the story is fairly basic: Nine beings called Polygons each named after digits live in the Palace of Polygor, where a huge machine makes all the numbers of the universe. This persisted in stasis for an indeterminable length of time until the arrival of the prophet Jzero, who inflicted some vague truth on the Polygons that changed their lives. Stevens came up with the idea after reading a book on Pythagoras while in Australia. "At first I couldn't see the point of making numbers any more important than what you use them for ... [then I] realized that I’d always known the importance of numbers without really being aware of it—like all songs have a natural 'three' element, three being the strongest number of all ... Then you start finding out that Pythagoras developed the Western musical scale. Then, thinking about it, you discover that the law of music is the same law that applies to nature as a whole, that your life has octaves in the same way as the musical scale does." (Cat Stevens Talks to Mick Brown, Sounds, December 13th, 1975)
The whimsical opening instrumental "Whistlestar" seems to have no overarching significance in the story except that maybe the "Whistlestar" is part of the "cluster of burning stars" that illuminates the Numbers galaxy. Reportedly, when Stevens played the song live, he would pop out of a box after a magician performed tricks over the course of the song. The dirge "Novim's Nightmare" chronicles Novim's (number nine) experience being revitalized following the arrival of Jzero. Stevens explained, "Yes, its a vision I have often in dreams. There's something so strong about that guillotine. The moment you're born, and through the whole of your life, there's a guillotine waiting ... The centre to the story of Numbers is that really you're in a place where everything seems immortal, eternal and everlasting. And suddenly along comes this question of death, which has never entered before. And then you start to question everything." (Cat Stevens—Life, Love and DeathMelody Maker, November 15th, 1975)
The slick "Majik of Majiks" is about "the power of zero [...] when you think you're smart and you've got it planned and then along comes this silly little accident and you're put back to square one [...] the ego having to face death finally." A Polygon (presumably still Novim, who now sees himself as an outcast) sings about the shocking revelation of Jzero, who "[has] the key to any door." The knowingly gospel-inflected "Drywood" continues these themes with a more uplifting tone, urging the Polygons or the listener to "Kick out your dull padded life" and begin anew.
The strange, jangling "Banapple Gas," which was the one minor hit from Numbers, seems to represent the change in routine that was occurring on Polygor. "Land o' Free Love and Goodbye" seems to be a more traditional song about the time Stevens lived in, mentioning God by name rather than an allegorical character. On the theme song "Jzero," the titular character speaks equivocally about his purpose, saying he only came to the palace for work and little food. The Polygons note that "He says he hasn't got nothing/But he seems to possess less," seeming to allude to religious concepts of material possession and elevating Jzero to a holy figure of sorts. The yearning "Home" describes a kind of utopia "where all mums can sing/Back where the children don't cry/Home where you never ask why and/Everybody has enough," but also bizarrely "you don't have to put on clothes/Nobody has to hide 'cause everyone already knows," which either means Stevens was singing generally again or that the Polygons ultimately decided to get nude with the townsfolk. In the closing "Monad's Anthem," Monad (number one), the Emperor, bellows about "one" as a female chorus echoes him, seemingly in glorification of Polygor.
Although very little of Numbers was that far removed from Stevens' usual musical fare—it featured his usual band, and only the uncharacteristic instrumental "Whistlestar" and obscure paean "Monad's Anthem" were new ground for him—its off-kilter qualities seemed to be too much for the public. The album began a downtown for him commercially, although it and the following Itizso (1977) still went Gold. There are some heavier introspective themes on it, especially on the first side with songs like "Novim's Nightmare," but in the end people only remembered the fanciful "Banapple Gas" if they held on to anything at all. Numbers, which are represented in modern times by Arabic numerals, were adumbrating subject matter for Cat Stevens; he did not convert to Islam until late 1977, so it's tough to assert that Jzero is analogous to Mohammed, though perhaps he is an amalgam of Mohammed and other figures such as Christ.
Overall, it can't definitively be said that Numbers is as musically satisfying as the rest of Cat Stevens' oeuvre. There's no "The Hurt" or "Father and Son" to anchor it, though the album as a whole is melodically satisfying, with just the right amount of intricacy here and there. Perhaps the public should have heeded the warning in the liner notes which read, "This album is not to be taken 2 seriously," though the intellectual parts of Numbers are actually rewarding. It's a minor gem from an artist that rarely went against the grain, and it didn't deserve the treatment it got.

20 December 2015

David Bowie—Hunky Dory

David Bowie—Hunky Dory
Hunky Dory—Usually regarded as David Bowie's first bona fide classic LP, Hunky Dory bears the overlooked quality of being a summation of the first segment of his career. David Bowie (1967) was a classicist excursion in early British Invasion and baroque pop, with a touch of the strangeness that would always be present in his work—the Beatles with a more archaic touch, essentially—David Bowie (1969), the second album to bear that title, often referred to as Space Oddity or Man of Words/Man of Music, mixed in progressive elements in the same manner as Syd Barrett's Pink Floyd, and The Man Who Sold the World (1970) furthered layered his sound with hard rock elements and obscure, dark, often maniacal lyrics. Hunky Dory is a step back from the last iteration, possibly a sign that producer Tony Visconti was responsible for the compression in sound—Visconti does not return in that role nor as Bowie's bassist as he had been on the previous two albums—but it does continue Bowie's move into more personal territory as well as observations on the latest in space fare.
"Changes," iconic for its stuttering chorus among all else, is also one of Bowie's best chord progressions, with some credit to Yes piano player Rick Wakeman. However, Bowie quickly tops himself in this respect with with "Oh! You Pretty Things," which esoterically honors outsiders. The pair of songs is interesting in the sense that both seem to embrace campy arrangements that are slyly undercut with hints of real meaning and true vision in melody that separate it from the novelty music that no doubt influenced them. The amusing but slight vignette "Eight Line Poem" was probably a real observance from Bowie. "Life on Mars?" has transcended its origins as a "My Way" parody to become one of Bowie's most rightly beloved space songs, mostly due to Mick Ronson's string arrangements. The idyllic "Kooks," written for Bowie's recently born son Duncan, is one of Bowie's most unmysterious songs ever; if it sounds vaguely like "Sugar Mountain," the Neil Young connection was deliberate. The abasing "Quicksand," which switches from mono to stereo near the end of the first passage, references the occult, Heinrich Himmler, Greta Garbo, and Winston Churchill in its apocalyptic vision, concluding, "Don't believe in yourself, don't deceive with belief/Knowledge comes with death's release."
"Fill Your Heart," the Biff Rose/Paul Williams composition, the first in a long series of once-per-album covers, fits right along with "Kooks," but it is interesting to note that the outtake "Bombers" was initially supposed to lead off the second side, which arguably better fits with the themes throughout the rest of the album. "Andy Warhol," a funny tribute to Bowie's friend with a killer acoustic arpeggio, was initially written to be performed by Dana Gillespie, just as "Oh! You Pretty Things" had been for Peter Noone (combined with the fact that Bowie had intended to write his own version of "Comme d'habitude" for Frank Sinatra, one must wonder if Bowie fantasized being a professional songwriter). The languid "Song for Bob Dylan," which came during Dylan's lean period in '71-'73 that saw very little progress from the artist, uses Dylan's own words against him ("Hey, hey, Woody Guthrie, I wrote you a song") in criticizing him for abdicating his lofty position in popular music. "Queen Bitch," the only indication that Bowie would get heavier in the years to come, ennobles Lou Reed. "The Bewlay Brothers" is a characteristic Bowie closer: complete nonsense (Bewlay being a brand of tobacco pipe) that nonetheless conveys his message effectively in texture.
By trimming the excesses from all aspects of his music (with help from new producer Ken Scott), David Bowie was able to make his most effective record to date with Hunky Dory. With the basic elements of his songs—that is to say, his singing and principal melodies—mixed in front, the world got to see just how inspired a songwriter he was, and it resulted in the first of many masterstrokes.

More David Bowie reviews by The Old Noise:

David Bowie (1967)
David Bowie (1969)
The Man Who Sold the World (1970)
Hunky Dory (1971)
The Rise and Fall of Ziggy Stardust and the Spiders from Mars (1972)
Aladdin Sane (1973)
Pin Ups (1973)
Diamond Dogs (1974)
Young Americans (1975)
Station to Station (1976)
Low (1977)
"Heroes" (1977)
Lodger (1979)
Scary Monsters (and Super Creeps) (1980)
Let's Dance (1983)
Tonight (1984)
Never Let Me Down (1987)
Black Tie White Noise (1993)
The Buddha of Suburbia (1993)
Outside (1995)
Earthling (1997)
'Hours...' (1999)
Heathen (2002)
Reality (2003)
The Next Day (2013)
Blackstar (2016)

06 September 2015

Miley Cyrus—Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz

Miley Cyrus—Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz
Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz—Is there redemption for teen idols? History has shown that corporate singers can go on to lead distinguished careers, like Scott Walker, though the very definition of a teen idol has changed dramatically since Walker's '60s. Miley Cyrus followed in a long line of Disney starlets-turned-pop singers from Britney Spears to Demi Lovato, though Cyrus was distinguished from the rest by coming from a family with actual musical heritage, however dubious: father Billy Ray Cyrus scored a #4 hit in 1992 with the reviled "Achy Breaky Heart" and followed it with a string of other country hits. Unlike Miley and her ilk, Billy Ray was a musician first and an actor second, whereas the Disney stars were bred to be general performers: act until you're not cute anymore, then pick up a microphone and start wearing less clothing.
It's a formula that's worked for a long line of starlets, and Miley Cyrus is no exception. After her Disney series Hannah Montana ended in 2011, her image began to change when the media took hold of non-events like Cyrus' remarking on her mild drug use or her twerking of Robin Thicke at the 2013 MTV Video Music Awards. The latter event helped generate notoriety for Bangerz, her first album for RCA, which was met with halfhearted reviews and platinum sales. As Cyrus embarked on the album's supporting tour, she seemed destined for years of pop banality when early in 2014, a strange thing happened:


A mainstream pop artist expressing admiration for an established rock act is nothing extraordinary in and of itself, but fans of the Flaming Lips would begin to look on in amazement as Cyrus and Wayne Coyne developed an actual friendship in the ensuing months. Coyne joined Cyrus on stage in Februrary for a performance of the Lips' "Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots, Pt. 1" and in March began to post photos of his band and Cyrus in the recording studio together.

The prospect of Cyrus and the Flaming Lips recording together was hard to swallow for most onlookers. Fans of Cyrus were generally unfamiliar with the Lips, and fans of the Lips did not care about or were skeptical of what Cyrus could bring to the mix. The collaborative sessions appeared to be unfocused and under no specific timetable, so for most of 2014 the only things that came of it were Cyrus' and Coyne's matching tattoos and a bizarre music video titled "Blonde SuperFreak Steals the Magic Brain." The Flaming Lips released With a Little Help from My Fwends in October, a song-for-song remake of Sgt Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band which featured Cyrus on the acid-washed renditions of "Lucy in the Sky with Diamonds" and "A Day in the Life," among many other artists.
The 22-year-old Cyrus and 54-year-old Coyne continued their platonic cavorting for nearly a year with no new material between the two and only some Instagram snippets to show for their work together. The prospective album seemed like a pipe dream until the 2015 MTV Video Music Awards, almost two years to the day after her twerking occurrence, when the two performed a new song, "Dooo It!" before Cyrus announced the independent release of Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz, free to stream on her website through the music service SoundCloud effective immediately. Cyrus and her cohorts sing, "Yeah I smoke pot/Yeah I love peace/But I don't give a fuck/I ain't no hippie." The vapid nature of the opening song is a clear attempt by Cyrus to alienate her existing audience, concluding with the puzzling lines, "Why they put the dick in the pussy/Fuck you." Wayne Coyne, his nephew Dennis of Stardeath and White Dwarfs, and Steven Drozd all share writing credits on it and variously on most other songs on the 92-minute album.
The pretty "Karen Don't Be Sad" is a resurrected Flaming Lips outtake from Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots, which explains the overarching similarities to that album's title piece, especially lines like "You know you're only letting 'em win," mirroring the battle between Yoshimi and the evil robots, but spun like an anti-bullying message. "The Floyd Song (Sunrise)" is a tribute to Cyrus' dog, whose death was the impetus for Coyne and Cyrus to get the aforementioned With a Little Help from My Fwends tattoos. The acoustic "Something about Space Dude" and its Oren Yoel-produced counterpart "Space Boots" as a pair blur the line between her experimental songs and her radio-ready material. Therein lies the genius of the album: by sequencing it like a jukebox from the nether, the group has made a grotesque pastiche of all the parts of Cyrus' personality, as it devolves into the cacophonous "Fuckin Fucked Up," back up into the spoken-word shuffle of "BB Talk," and into the Mike Will Made It-produced ballad "Fweaky" and wanton "Bang Me Box."
"Milky Milky Milk" opens up a new Lips suite, building around a sample of "Try to Explain" from The Terror with lines like "Your lips get me so wet/While I'm singing all the verses from the Tibetan Book of Dead." On "Slab of Butter (Scorpion)," it's amusing to see that after branding each of the songs he worked on in narcissistic fashion, Mike Will Made It is now associated with a song whose chorus is, "I feel like a slab of butter that is melting in the sun." "I Forgive Yiew" is pure pop, while the lovely "I Get So Scared" touches on indie guitar pop, "Lighter" a sort of mellower new wave. "Tangerine" mixes Lips spaceship imagery with a disaffected post-party passage by Big Sean"Tiger Dreams," featuring Ariel Pink, is a despondent number about the futility of the world.
"Evil Is a Shadow" is a highlight, sounding as if it could slot perfectly anywhere on At War with the Mystics or Embryonic"Cyrus Skies" apotheosizes the broadening of the mind: "Yeah I've been alive/But I've been a liar/There's some kind of love/That's so much higher." "1 Sun" is performed and mixed in the vein of Lady Gaga with Cyrus referencing artistic predecessor (to both) Grace Jones"Miley Tibetan Bowlzzz" sees Cyrus' chants echoing over Drozd's new age synthesizer, while the tragicomical "Pablow the Blowfish" continues the theme of Cyrus' unfortunate run of titular pets. The album then ends with the personal triumph of "Twinkle Song," where Cyrus sings, "I had a dream/David Bowie ... was shaped like Gumby."
Speaking of Miley Cyrus' musical merit, Miley Cyrus & Her Dead Petz would likely not be as good as it is without the involvement of the Flaming Lips. It's tempting to say that her input is secondary to what was accomplished around her, but it's pleasing to see that she's willing to go in a more challenging musical direction, even if there are some failed experiments like "BB Talk" and forgettable drek like "Bang Me Box." That is to be expected, however, especially on a 23-track album, and there are certainly more hits than misses. The unlikely friendship finally bearing fruit, Petz bodes well for Cyrus as an artist and is simultaneously a pleasant entry in the eclectic career of the Flaming Lips.

01 September 2015

The Flaming Lips—Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots

The Flaming Lips—Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots
Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots—The 1990s were a transformative decade for the Flaming Lips. It began with their fourth album, In a Priest Driven Ambulance (1990)—feedback-laden yet radiant alt-rock in the vein of the Soft Boys—and ended with the idiosyncratic, career-defining, career-redefining The Soft Bulletin (1999). Clouds Taste Metallic (1995) was sci-fi lite; its weird-science lyrics came off like comic book storylines, simultaneously more grounded than the acid trips of their first six albums and yet still more difficult for its implications of more complex emotion. The quadruple-disc Zaireeka (1997) was largely ignored by the general populace for its difficult concept, but it was certainly the beginning of the Flaming Lips part two. The Soft Bulletin focused that experimentation into more conventional recordings to universal acclaim. The band entered the new millennium with a sound all their own.
Never an album-per-year band, the Flaming Lips spent the next two years crafting their follow-up. The Soft Bulletin was an all-encompassing record sonically, so expanding their sound was a tall task. The band further developed their metaphysical concepts and came up with Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots, the titular character being named for Wayne Coyne's inspiration Yoshimi P-We, who performs the Japanese-language segments on the album. The wistfully impellent "Fight Test" quickly became infamous for its similarities to "Father and Son" by Cat Stevens (Yusuf Islam), both in melodic progression and general sentiment. While it is fatally derivative, "Fight Test" has enough in its favor to allow individual appreciation, from the summery ambiance reminiscent of XTC to the gentle weaving of the verses at its consummation. The catalyst for the potential conflict is only made clear by the line, "If I could, I would, but you're with him now it'd do no good." The song leads into the cold "One More Robot/Sympathy 3000‒21," an affecting play at emotional numbness.
The winning run continues with the saccharine innocence of "Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots, Pt. 1," which highlights the only thing that was missing from The Soft Bulletin: a true standout, which they deliver here, the chords pure pop, the story genuine in its foibles. Coyne went so far as to record a Japanese version sung by himself for the single release, which is reported to be sung with less-than-perfect inflection. "Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots, Pt. 2" introduces another item to the mix to less favorable effect: noise, which isn't pointless per se—it can be seen both as a representation of the battle between Yoshimi and the robots and a tribute to OOIOO—but it does lack nuance just as a piece of music. "In the Morning of the Magicians" is more or less pleasing, though unvaried across more than six minutes.
The abyssal, pathetic "Ego Tripping at the Gates of Hell" continues the theme of bare, unrequited longing. "Are You a Hypnotist??" comes off like a chant from a desert planet. The cuckoo chords that open "It's Summertime" belie one of the Lips' simplest songs before they launch into the soaring, jangling "Do You Realize??" which became one of their most enduring songs, despite disarming the listener with the self-evident musing, "Do you realize/That everyone you know someday will die?" The final vocal piece, "All We Have Is Now," is an underrated, apocalyptic story of meeting one's self from the future only to hear that there is no future. The closing instrumental "Approaching Pavonis Mons by Balloon (Utopia Planitia)" is a successful (and in fact Grammy-winning) trip to the smallest volcano of Mars' Tharsis Montes (note that while the Flaming Lips are known for their fantastic ideas, aerobots actually are sent into outer space by balloon).
Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots is not every bit the equal of The Soft Bulletin. It shouldn't be held to that standard, though it's a respectable sequel in any case, but its songs are often too lethargic: a quality that has admittedly worked well for the band at times, but not when the songs are as slight as "It's Summertime." On the other hand, its best songs, which are tellingly assembled mostly at the front, arguably surpass the high points of Bulletin, proving the Lips masters of their own craft. Sometimes that makes all the difference in the world.

16 June 2015

Squeeze—Argybargy

Squeeze—Argybargy
Argybargy—It's a tall task for a singles band to put together a respectable album. It has proven difficult since the inception of the album format, and some artists, no matter how talented, aren't best represented by it; they may be more focused on individual compositions, in which case not every one will be a gem, but they still need to fill an LP. This is definitely true in the case of Squeeze, whose first two albums, Squeeze (1978) and Cool for Cats (1979), were decidedly uneven. One would expect the approach might be different with their third album, Argybargy, but there really wasn't—the songs were just better, bullet for bullet.
Like Cool for Cats, Chris Difford's lyrics recount seemingly prosaic stories and events, even touching on observational humor. "Pulling Mussels (from the Shell)" is the successor to Cats' titular closing piece, picking up right where Squeeze left off. Where that album roiled with camp, plodding on every other cut with a sense of limited novelty, Glenn Tilbrook's Argybargy melodies are prettier, finding better uses for keyboardist Jools Holland's whimsical playing. "Another Nail in My Heart" is the greatest pop single of its time, immaculately crafted with its cleverly-misplaced bridge: the greatest snapshot of the band's talents. "Separate Beds" is a more innocent boy-girl song than is typical for Difford, and so it is knowingly understated, but still sweet. What really sets Argybargy apart from its predecessors—which despite their faults, had singles as good as anything Squeeze ever did—is songs like "Misadventure," which combines the colorful imagery of "Take Me I'm Yours" with the playfulness of the otherwise-valueless "Touching Me Touching You." Similarly, "I Think I'm Go Go" is an upgrade on "The Knack," utilizing more of the band's strengths where before they were flat and uncharacteristically minimal.
"Farfisa Beat" is the only real throwaway, a dismally catchy piece of nonsense that was somewhat insultingly released as a single in select European countries. Welcome for its dynamic interplay is "Here Comes That Feeling," Difford's esoteric, intrusive thinking that underpins many of his stories, much like contemporary Elvis Costello. "Vicky Verky" is a transparent follow-up to "Up the Junction," bordering on self-plagiarism but ultimately pleasing with its uptempo keyboard rush. "If I Didn't Love You" was Squeeze's minor breakthrough on U.S. radio, more straightforward and seductive than the playful pub poppers that made them popular in their home country of England. Third vocalist Jools Holland takes on the effervescent "Wrong Side of the Moon," which is a solid tune despite its ostensibly careless nature; "There at the Top" somehow comes off as more questionable by comparison, bordering on derisive.
It should be said that Argybargy feels slightly underweight, and this is no coincidence. Squeeze originally recorded 14 songs for the album that A&M trimmed to 11; "Someone Else's Heart" would be reused for East Side Story the following year, "Funny How It Goes" was effectively the title song under the album's original name (It's a Funny Old World), and "What the Butler Saw" was instead used as the b-side to the single of "Pulling Mussels (from the Shell)." This is unfortunate, as the three bolster the set—fortunately, modern releases of the album include them and they are otherwise easy to find. Even without them, however, Argybargy is an impressive pop record with superlative material, and for Squeeze it became their first LP that was truly worth owning.

13 May 2015

Tom Waits—Closing Time

Tom Waits—Closing Time
Closing Time—Before there was "Time," there was Closing Time. Today, Tom Waits is at once a Grammy winner and a cult figure, a duality demonstrable by the body of songs written by Waits but called to attention by others. Prolific singer Rod Stewart, Meat Loaf, and even Scarlett Johansson are three of many; fans of E Street Radio may hear "Jersey Girl" from the native, and those who watch all five seasons of The Wire will have heard five arrangements of "Way Down in the Hole." While Waits is far from the caliber of influence predecessor Bob Dylan holds, the point stands that one who ingests information media has very possibly heard Tom Waits. But back in 1973, Closing Time wasn't exactly a smash, not recognized until the likes of Tim Buckley (himself undervalued) and the Eagles took on its songs. Looking back, it's easy to see why they did: the songs are easy to pick up and play, yet they have a distinctive excellence that leaves musicians wondering how they didn't write them first.
It seems retrospectively logical that the band who would later write "Life in the Fast Lane" covered "Ol' '55." Waits' original begins the album on a gentle note, belying its amusing inspiration from a friend who had to drive in reverse on the Pasadena Freeway to get his underage date home.1 Beyond that, the song perfectly places the listener in the driver's seat, watching the sun rise and the "stars beginning to fade." "I Hope That I Don't Fall in Love with You" seems a strange sentiment at first glance, but perfectly captures the fear that comes with falling in love, perhaps at first sight or perhaps just in theory. Its lines "I had a beer and now I hear you calling out for me" and "I turn around to look at you/You're nowhere to be found/I search the place for your lost face/Guess I'll have another round" suggest that the source of his infatuation may be imaginary. It may be coincidence that the song is followed by the drunken regret of "Virginia Avenue," a theme that would be explored more explicitly on Small Change (1976) and parts of other releases.
"Old Shoes (& Picture Postcards)" is a song so perfect in its arrangement, naturally flowing and idyllic in atmosphere that it sounds like a standard, a tale of a breakup without remorse—for the author, at least. "Midnight Lullaby" is a modern twist on the old-time lullaby, spun more for a lover than a child, with a "Hush Little Baby" quote to boot. The side one closer "Martha" is the centerpiece, a dreamy, wistful piece where Waits refers to himself under a partial pseudonym. There is a stronger sense of the bittersweet here than anywhere else, probably because it seems to be the most personal of the album's songs. "Rosie" is the flip side of it, a lighter affair that suggests more a passing infatuation than longing. "Lonely" speaks to a mood rather than a particular thought, successfully attaining the image denoted by its title with its lack of accompaniment.
If there is any one point in Waits' early canon that forecast the Howlin' Wolf-inspired second phase of his career, it's "Ice Cream Man." While the performance is not exactly the long-lost cousin of "16 Shells from a Thirty-Ought-Six," his classicist euphemism echoing those of legendary bluesmen. "Little Trip to Heaven (On the Wings of Your Love)" is another classic, not impressing with its diminished-chord progression or its simple astronomical metaphors but the interplay between the two. "Grapefruit Moon" is heavy-heart nostalgia, functioning almost as a two-part conclusion with the instrumental "Closing Time" to sum up the feelings and concepts of the album while rounding out the jazz modality present throughout.
It's hard to say whether an artist like Tom Waits has a magnum opus when his discography is bursting with masterpieces or works that come very close. Closing Time is not his best or even his most consistent work, even if it would be considered those in most artists' catalogs. However, it is one of the best song-oriented works in all of popular music, being referred to as such only because of its seamless aggregate of rock, folk, and jazz. It's hard to say there's a work of music everyone could appreciate, but if there's any album that has a lot of universal appeal, it's Closing Time.





1 Waits, VH1 Storytellers, 1999.